Article analysis
301 permanent redirect → depends on → Review of core-question and valid-content coverage
The original article's section on choosing URL actions makes adequate content coverage a prerequisite for an appropriate permanent redirect in article consolidation. This is an editorial decision rule, not a technical requirement of HTTP. Google's migration guidance supplies background on URL mapping and relevant destinations, rather than proving the author's application to article merging.
Read the evidence
Only after confirming that an existing page covers its core question and valid content is it appropriate to permanently point the old URL to that page.
Background sources for the article's reasoning: [S3] Google Search Central
Read the full research